Denisova Nataliia, Buialska Nataliia
Chernihiv National University of Technology, Chernihiv, Ukraine
Title: Ensuring air quality in the work area when forming polyamide threads
Paper Type: Research Paper
City, Country: Chernihiv, Ukraine
Authors: N. Denisova, N. Buialska
the number of occupational diseases of operators affect the need for the studies of
discharge mechanism of pollutants and activities for the reduction of increased concentrations
of polluting compounds in the air of working area. Following studies of
sanitary and hygienic work conditions and pollutant discharges of low molecular weight
compounds (LMWC) of caprolactam in the work area during the formation of polyamide
threads it was revealed that the largest number of LMWC discharges are in the areas
of high turbulence air of blower ducts. A complex of methods for the labor protection
based on the research of air condition and particle distribution along the height of the
ducts and in the production area is proposed. This comprehensive solution includes
predictive control of blowing air pressure and formation temperature, as well as identifying
a minimum pollution location to place control room equipment in. Implementation
of the developed methods will lead to reducing the risk of elevated concentrations of
hazardous substances and ensuring the ambient air quality in the production area.
- Azarov N (2004) Comprehensive assessment of the dusting situation and the development of measures to reduce dusting in the air environment of industrial enterprises. Dissertation, Rostov-on-Don National University of Technology.
- Bhuvanech Y, Gupta V (1990) Computer simulation of melt spinning of poly (ethylene terephthalate) using a steady-state model. Indian Journal of Textile Research, 4: 145-153.
- Denisova N, Ivanova I (2005) Formation of polycaproamide. Some issues of labour protection. Vestnik Chernigovskogo gosudarstvennogo tekhnologіcheskogo unіversiteta, 25: 90-93.
- Denisova N (2010) Reducing air pollution levels in the work area during the formation of polyamide threads. Dissertation, National research Institute of industrial safety and labour protection.
- Pankeev A, Cherednichenko P, Korneeva S (2005) The research and modeling of the process of threads chilling during forming.Chernigov.
Considering the occupational safety in manufacturing of polyamide fibres through a chain of manufacturing processes (polymer synthesis, preparation of spinning paste for thread forming, formation of threads, their heat treatment and drawing, and textile use), and based on the analysis of the plant working conditions, there was revealed a risk of elevated concentrations of low molecular weight compounds in operators’ workplace ambient air.
The relevance of research on pollutant discharges of low molecular weight compounds (LMWC) of caprolactam and its oligomers is explained by an increased incidence of respiratory diseases among polyamide thread-forming operators with an almost fourfold excess of MPC (MPCukr. = 10 mg/m3) .
Therefore, the work is aimed to ensure air quality in the work area of thread-forming operators, and, consequently, to create better working conditions and reduce the incidence rate of workers. To comply with the EU standard for caprolactam (cl) aerosol concentrations in the work area air (5 mg/m3) will be an important task.
The parameters of ambient air were controlled using a standard technique in compliance with sanitary regulations DSN – 3.3.6.042-99. The technological parameters of the manufacturing process and the quality characteristics of threads were monitored in compliance with standard GOST 2263-2002. The ejection and turbulence areas in the blower duct were studied using a directed flow of soap bubbles. A point-estimate method was developed to carry out experimental studies of LMWC discharges and their distribution in the work area air. The experimental results were assessed by methods of mathematical statistics and systems analysis (two-factor variance analysis of effects of distance and time spent by operators in the polluted area, least-squares method for development of mathematical models of pollutant discharges and predictive control of airflow, mathematical method of linear programming to establish minimum values to locate minimally polluted safe areas). We used Microsoft Excel, OpenOffice Calc and MathCad.
Analysis and discussion of the results of experimental studies
Effects of caprolactam concentrations in the forming work area air on the incidence of operators’ respiratory diseases were assessed using a comprehensive approach aimed to creating a safe and healthy working environment and based on the results of monitoring air pollution in the work area, production workload and incidence rate .
After processing the data collected at Chernigovskoe chimvolokno OJSC, it was established that the incidence of respiratory diseases in workers is directly proportional to concentrations of caprolactam in the air (Сcl):
ζ = а + b ·Сcl,
where ζ – specific incidence rate (number of respiratory diseases per 100 people per year),
a, b – constants.
The constant a defines a relatively constant number of respiratory diseases that is independent of the working environment, and b·Сcl is a criterion for increasing the number of diseases caused by elevated concentrations of hazardous substances in the air. Modifying this parameter can not only reduce the number of respiratory diseases, but also bring significant economic benefits.
Using a correlation coefficient of 0.85, the equation is represented as follows:
ζ = 44,84 + 8,53 · Ccl. (1)
Considering the above, it was established that decreasing the concentration by 1.0 mg/m3 reduces the total number of respiratory diseases in workers by 16%.
The studies showed that decreasing LMWC discharges from blower ducts is a necessary but not sufficient condition for work safety of thread-forming operators. This issue requires a comprehensive solution that includes not only reducing the risk for exposure to a pollution source in technology terms, but also reconstruction of general and local ventilation systems, reducing working shifts time, placing control room equipment in areas with minimal air pollution, use of personal protective equipment for respiratory protection (PPERP) by workers.
For operators, the risk of staying inside the work area with consideration for pollutants distribution in it was assessed using the elaborated point-estimate method for estimation of LMWC discharges . The data were processed using two-factor variance analysis, where the factors were the distance and the time of the operator’s exposure within the hazardous area, and the response function was sediment accumulations on test indicators. The analysis showed that the most hazardous area in terms of air pollution is located at 0.5 m from the front edge of the blower duct. Pollutant accumulation on this site is increased by about 10% per hour. Since the operator workplace is within this distance, the use of PPERP is required, and the shift time may be reduced as dictated by specific conditions of production.
Minimally polluted areas suitable for the operator’s stay were selected using point method findings, where measurement points were placed over the entire area. A design diagram of pollution flow directions is shown in Fig. 1.
The experimental research data were processed using the linear programming method with search for minimum through flows . Calculations show that the minimum air pollution in the thread-forming area is located at points 3, 11, 12. It was found out that the optimal place for control room equipment would be an area (see Fig. 1, an area near point 12) 1.5 times less polluted than the average for the site, and 6.5 times less polluted than in the area of maximum discharges.
Air supplied by general ventilation was estimated using a point method for assessing pollution. Since the supply-and-exhaust ventilation in thread-forming areas adds blowing air to forced air, the following equation was used for calculations:
Ccl = (·n·k·Sd)/[Sti·(V1+V2·n)], (2)
where is the average weight of sediment on test indicators;
n – number of blower (working) ducts;
k – factor of conversion of point method data to LMWC concentration defined by standard methods (experimentally, k = 2,17);
Sd – front surface area of the blower duct, m2;
Sti – surface area of test indicator, m2;
V1, V2 – air supplied to the area and a separate workplace, respectively, m3/h.
Using known values of , n, V1, this equation allows to calculate a nomogram (Fig. 2: 1 – tf = 548 К; 2 ‒ tf = 555 К; 3 ‒ tf = 567 К) to determine V2 required to ensure a given LMWC concentration under any changes in process variables, the number of workplaces and the range of threads.
On the basis of the above, the rise of formation temperature tf up to 567 K leads to increasing of LMWC concentrations at all process levels except for the blower air pressure, P = 294 Pa. Therefore, the inflow changes slightly at this temperature. When tf = 555 K and tf = 548 K, pressure reduction leads to increasing Ccl concentrations and requires a significant increase in air exchange. When the area performance changes at constant parameters of threads cooling, V1 is directly proportional to the number of workplaces. A change in the shop productivity also leads to a change in formation rate and linear density of threads, and requires new values for factors and V1 of the equation (2).
Applying the above method to other factories manufacturing anide polyamide, polyester and polyamide threads of another linear density requires updated quantitative values of the factors that affect airflow.
Manufacturing application of the developed methods can reduce concentrations of pollutants (caprolactam) in the air of forming areas by ΔСcl = 43% (calculated using the equation (2)), meet the international standards for caprolactam aerosol concentrations in the work area air (5 mg/m3), and reduce the incidence of respiratory diseases in workers by Δζ = 28% (calculated using the equation (1)).
The solutions obtained can be used not only in manufacturing other ranges of polyamide threads, but also in manufacturing polyester, anide polyamide and other synthetic threads, which are formed in a similar pattern of melting. They also can be used to improve the engineering, economical and environmental performance of closed ducts.
Implementation of air pollution-reducing methods at thread-forming operator workplaces also has a social effect and an economic impact on the overall plant performance, which leads to increasing the professional activity period of workers and labour productivity, reducing staff turnover and sick leave costs paid by a company, savings in raw materials that evaporate and are irretrievably lost .
It was developed a set of methods to improve sanitary and hygienic work conditions of thread-forming operators; this makes possible to reduce concentrations of pollutant discharges of LMWC in the air of thread-forming areas by 43%, and meet the international standards for caprolactam aerosol concentrations in the air of thread-forming areas (5 mg/m3). As a result, the number of respiratory diseases in workers will be decreased by 28%. In addition to the process method, this comprehensive solution includes predictive control of LMWC concentrations in the work area air in case of process modifications, and a formula that takes into account the simultaneous intake of blower air and general dilution air to ensure air quality in the work area.
- Denisova N.M. Formation of polycaproamide. Some issues of labour protection/ N.M. Denisova, I.M. Ivanova // Vestnik Chernigovskogo gosudarstvennogo tekhnologіcheskogo unіversiteta. – Chernigov, 2005, 25: 90-93.
- Denisova N.M. Developing methods for estimating air pollution levels in the work area of forming equipment operators / N.M. Denisova // Problemy okhrany truda v Ukraine. – Kiev: 2009, 6:71-80.
- Denisova N.M. Forming polyamide threads. Developing methods for determining minimum polluted areas / Н.М. Denisova, A.L. Gumeniuk // Vestnik Chernigovskogo gosudarstvennogo tekhnologіcheskogo unіversiteta. – Chernigov, 2005, 36: 133-138.
- Denisova N.M. Reducing air pollution levels in the work area during the formation of polyamide threads. Author’s abstract of the dissertation on competition of a scientific degree of the candidate technical: Speciality 05.26.01 – Labour Protection / N.M. Denisova. – K., 2010, 20 p.